Feedback | SoME

Order of Forces and Energies #SoME4

Audience:

Tags: calculusphysicsenergyforce

A combination and modification of these two videos(https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x4XOjmq0RyY and https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8iMHSofF9p4) that I made previously to enter the #SoME4. It is about a generalization of the concepts of force and energy that I made while analizing a animated series however, it can still be applied to the real world. Made with manim and kdenlive

Analytics

3.02 Overall score*

174 Rank

6 Votes

4 Comments

Comments

2.5

This seems somewhat imprecise, and it wasn’t clear why these generalizations of force and energy would be useful. The motivation for discrete motion also didn’t seem to continue beyond the initial part of the video.

I’m really sorry, but the model you’re presenting here is directly self-contradictory, fails to grasp the relationships between things like work and kinetic energy as they exist in real-life physics on a deeper level, you don’t show how it could actually be used practically in any relevant examples, and you don’t really get into what other thing you are trying to model with these new concepts

6.1

The concept of order n forces/energies seems new and unexplored. Follow up questions would be applicability and variations.

2.5

If it is intended for students, this video has a problem: too many formulas, some simple and others advanced. Moreover, the lesson is very similar to a traditional lecture, offering nothing particularly original or engaging.